General Liability
-
August 14, 2024
Insurer Fights $29M Judgment Over Fatal Crash Coverage
An insurer urged a North Carolina state appeals court Wednesday to undo a nearly $29 million judgment in a lawsuit stemming from a claim for a fatal vehicle crash, citing a policy exclusion that barred coverage for injuries to fellow employees.
-
August 14, 2024
Insurer Off Hook For Jury Award In Construction Dispute
A commercial insurer does not have to indemnify a contractor found liable for multiple structural and other problems in a home he built, a Massachusetts intermediate appellate court concluded Wednesday in a case of first impression involving what is considered "property damage" in a construction dispute.
-
August 14, 2024
Mich. Court Stands By Unitary Biz Ruling For Nationwide
A Michigan state appeals court will not reconsider its decision that insurance companies that are part of Nationwide should file their taxes as a unitary group, and denied the state Treasury Department's request for reconsideration.
-
August 13, 2024
Texas AG Targets General Motors Over Unlawful Data Sales
Texas' attorney general has escalated his probe into data privacy practices at connected car manufacturers, hitting General Motors with a lawsuit in state court Tuesday accusing the automaker of unlawfully gathering and selling drivers' private data — which would then be resold to insurance companies — without permission.
-
August 13, 2024
1st Circ. Kicks UIM Coverage Battle To RI Justices
The First Circuit asked the Rhode Island Supreme Court to consider the extent an individual who is injured in an auto accident during the scope of their employment is entitled to underinsured motorist coverage under their employer's policy, saying "insurance law is notoriously complex and today's appeal proves that point."
-
August 13, 2024
3rd Circ. Refers Sex Traffic Coverage Issues To Pa. Justices
The Third Circuit asked the Pennsylvania Supreme Court to consider whether an insurer's duty to defend and indemnify is repealed when an insured is accused of enabling or profiting from sex trafficking, telling Pennsylvania's high court that the decision has far-reaching state and public implications.
-
August 13, 2024
Contractors Owe $7M For Iron Plant Fire, Insurer Says
An insurer for one of the world's largest steel producers told a Texas federal court that five companies it said were responsible for the design, manufacture, sale and installation of a failed component at an iron plant must foot the bill for a fire that cost the producer nearly $7 million.
-
August 13, 2024
Ski Resort, Insurer End COVID Closure Suit Days Before Trial
Colorado ski resort company Alterra and its insurer agreed to settle a lawsuit over coverage for coronavirus pandemic shutdowns, shortly after a state judge limited Alterra's potential recovery to $1 million.
-
August 12, 2024
Insurer Says No Coverage For Hotel In Sex Trafficking Case
An insurer told a Virginia federal judge it didn't owe coverage to a hotel owner accused of participating in sex trafficking at its Super 8 Motel turned Quality Inn, because criminal acts were not covered under state rules or by the policy.
-
August 08, 2024
No Private Right To Sue After 'Total Loss,' Colo. Panel Says
Colorado policyholders cannot sue their auto insurers to enforce a statute requiring them to cover vehicles' title and registration fees when vehicles are declared a total loss, a Colorado appeals court ruled Thursday, finding the statute contains no implied private right of action.
-
August 08, 2024
Illinois Biometric Privacy Reform Eases Coverage Woes
Illinois reformed its biometric privacy law that started a wave of litigation by limiting the potential liabilities for sharing biometric data without informed consent, which experts said will ease the coverage concerns of both policyholders and insurers.
-
August 08, 2024
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
The Eleventh Circuit rejected insurers' coverage challenges in separate suits over a wood-theft settlement and a storm damage appraisal award, a Georgia federal court ordered an insurer to defend a farm in a couple's suit over foul smells, and the Eighth Circuit said Geico had no duty to cover a woman's HPV claims. Here, Law360 takes a look at the past week's top insurance news.
-
August 08, 2024
8th Circ. Avoids 'Absurd Results' In Geico HPV Suit
While the Eighth Circuit reasonably interpreted a Geico auto policy as not providing coverage for a woman's claim that she contracted HPV during sexual encounters in a policyholder's car, carriers should heed the case as a warning to draft clearer policy language, policyholder and insurer-side attorneys alike agreed.
-
August 08, 2024
Community Insurance Can Plug NFIP Gaps, Expert Says
Community-based flood insurance can help cover insurance gaps and provide fast insurance relief to towns and cities at risk of flooding, UC Davis researcher and former Federal Emergency Management Agency engineer Kathleen Schaefer tells Law360.
-
August 08, 2024
Conflicting Rulings Muddy Del. Stance On No-Action Clause
Conflicting Delaware state court rulings on the enforcement of no-action clauses in liability insurance policies have called into question the compatibility of such clauses with an insurer's duty to defend, policyholder experts say.
-
August 08, 2024
Colo. Judge Limits Ski Co.'s COVID Insurance Recovery
An owner and operator of 15 ski resorts claiming roughly $200 million in COVID-19-related losses can recover only up to $1 million under its AIG policy's "loss of attraction" provision, a Colorado state court ruled, leaving nearly all other coverage issues up to a jury to decide.
-
August 07, 2024
11th Circ. Affirms Unapportioned Wood-Theft Settlement
The Eleventh Circuit has unanimously upheld a Georgia federal court ruling forcing an insurer to cover a $557,000 settlement for shoddy work and wood theft during a deconstruction project by its policyholder, despite objections from the insurer that the amount was not apportioned between covered and noncovered losses.
-
August 07, 2024
Mich. Insurance Agency Pushes Carriers To Safeguard AI Use
The Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services urged insurance companies Wednesday to establish a program for the responsible use of artificial intelligence systems to comply with state laws barring unfair practices and discrimination in underwriting.
-
August 06, 2024
Motorola, Phone Biz Denied $1.5M From Defunct Co.'s Insurer
Cellphone maker Motorola and a phone and internet provider cannot get coverage for more than $1.5 million in judgments they won against a defunct marketing services company from that company's insurer, a Minnesota appeals court ruled, finding separate professional services and illegal profit exclusions apply.
-
August 06, 2024
Blank Rome Adds Closed Insurance Boutique's Managing Atty
Blank Rome LLP has brought on an insurance partner from now-shuttered boutique Pasich LLP to join its insurance recovery group, the firm announced Monday.
-
August 06, 2024
Farm Stench Insurance Coverage Case Saved By The Bugs
A Georgia couple accusing their poultry-farming neighbors of wafting putrid smells and failing to contain insects birthed upon their property succeeded Tuesday in forcing the farm's insurer to defend the business thanks to the bugs, a Georgia federal judge ruled.
-
August 05, 2024
Manufacturer Can't Get Coverage For BIPA Class Action
An Illinois federal judge awarded a win to an insurer Monday in a suit over coverage of underlying Biometric Information Privacy Act litigation, finding a contractual exclusion prevented coverage for a machine and plastics manufacturer accused of failing to secure employee data.
-
August 05, 2024
Insurer Must Face Pa. Trans Firefighter's Surgery Claim
A Pennsylvania federal judge has refused to toss a suit from a transgender Philadelphia firefighter suing Independence Blue Cross for discrimination over the insurer's denial of coverage for facial feminization surgery, finding that claims under federal healthcare law could proceed, but not the Title VII claims.
-
August 05, 2024
Pa. Utility Says Insurer Must Cover Spinoff Defense Costs
A Pennsylvania-based utility company told a federal court that its excess directors and officers insurer failed to cover any portion of the $53.4 million it incurred defending underlying lawsuits related to the spinoff of a subsidiary, noting that its primary insurer already paid its full $20 million limit.
-
August 02, 2024
Wolverine, Travelers Drop Coverage Claims Over PFAS Suits
Footwear company Wolverine and various Travelers units have agreed to end their coverage battle over underlying lawsuits accusing the company of injuring individuals through its leather tannery operations and exposing individuals to so-called forever chemicals, the parties told a Michigan federal court.
Expert Analysis
-
The Lawyer Personalities That Make Up Joint Interest Groups
As multiparty litigation rises and forces competing law firms to work together, George Reede at Zelle looks at the different personalities — from tactful synthesizers to misguided Don Quixotes — that often make up joint representation groups, and how lawyers can overcome the tensions in these and other team settings.
-
NJ High Court Ruling Doesn't Negate Insurer Duty To Defend
The New Jersey Supreme Court's decision in Norman v. Admiral Insurance, finding a narrow exception to the duty to defend, doesn't allow insurers to skip out on their litigation defense obligations, say Eric Jesse and Seth Fiur at Lowenstein Sandler.
-
Fla. Evidence Code Update Lowers Burden For Image Use
Florida's recent evidence code change permits judicial notice of images and certain other graphics, a hugely meaningful development for litigants across a wide range of practice areas, though the effect will likely be immediately felt in property insurance cases, say Eve Cann and David Levin at Baker Donelson.
-
7th Circ. 'Reasonable Costs' Ruling Is A Win For Policyholders
The Seventh Circuit's decision in USA Gymnastics v. Liberty Insurance last month establishes useful precedent for policyholders, affirming and expanding on its rule that defense costs are presumed to be reasonable and necessary when insurers breach their duty to defend, say attorneys at Reed Smith.
-
A Road Map To Insurance For PFAS Claims And Suits
In light of an uptick in regulation and litigation surrounding per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, product manufacturers potentially facing down massive liability settlements must properly investigate and understand the full scope of insurance available, says Jodi Green at Miller Nash.
-
Forecasting A Rise In 11th Circ. State Court Class Actions
Two recent opinions from the Eleventh Circuit have created an unusual landscape that may result in a substantial increase of class action litigation in state courts, particularly in Florida, that will be unable to utilize removal tools such as the Class Action Fairness Act, says Alec Schultz at Hilgers Graben.
-
Readying Companies For PFAS Regulation And Liability
Managing the uptick in regulatory oversight of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances and the potential civil liability for companies will require action now, from performing audits and reviewing insurance coverage to considering the Texas two-step merger method, say attorneys at Haynes and Boone.
-
Contra Proferentem Will Remain Alive And Well In NY
Although a recent Law360 guest article argues that a New York state court's decision in Brooklyn Union Gas v. Century Indemnity creates a blanket exception to the principle that contractual ambiguities are construed against the drafter, leading appellate decisions suggest that the exception would only be applied under narrow circumstances, say attorneys at Pillsbury.
-
Pa. Cannabis Banking Law Won't Allay Finance Industry Fears
Though a new Pennsylvania law allows financial institutions and insurers to provide services to the state’s legal cannabis industry, it’s unlikely to assuage most financial industry operators’ fears of federal reprisal, and their reluctance to work with cannabis businesses will surely persist, says Michael Sampson at Leech Tishman.
-
NY Insurance Ruling Reveals Limits Of Contra Proferentem
A New York state court's decision in Brooklyn Union Gas v. Century Indemnity, finding that there's no need to construe an ambiguous policy against an insurer when the policyholder is a sophisticated company, shows that contesting the application of the contra proferentem rule is gaining more traction in courts, say John Ewell and Joanna Roberto at Gerber Ciano.
-
What Wis. Anti-Assignment Ruling Means For Policyholders
A Wisconsin state court's recent decision in Pepsi-Cola v. Employers Insurance Co. of Wausau makes pivotal the question of when a loss occurs, meaning that policyholders subject to anti-assignment clauses cannot simply rely on plain contractual language, say Brian Scarbrough and Daniel Ergas at Jenner & Block.
-
Taming Plaintiffs' Thriving 'Reptile' Tactics: How To Start
As rising social inflation increases the danger of plaintiffs attorneys' reptile tactics, which appeal to primal emotions instead of logic, defendants should carefully consider 22 strategies that can be employed in pretrial strategy or via traditional courtroom tools, say Scott Seaman and Diane Webster at Hinshaw.
-
Taming Plaintiffs' Thriving 'Reptile' Tactics: Why It's Time
As insurers and corporate policyholders are looking down the dangerous double barrel of price level and social inflation, it's important to examine what they can do to contain a leading driver of social inflation — plaintiffs lawyers' reptile theory, which positions jurors as guardians against dangers for society, say Scott Seaman and Diane Webster at Hinshaw.