Property
-
September 24, 2024
Calif. Panel Frees Insurer From $7.5M Dog Attack Judgment
A California appeals court panel affirmed an insurer didn't owe any part of a $7.5 million judgment for a dog attack, finding a homeowner's policy excluding coverage for injuries caused by a pit bull clearly applied to the homeowner's sister's dog, Bugzy.
-
September 23, 2024
Adjuster Has No Duty To Insured In La. Hurricane Row
A Louisiana federal judge ruled Monday that an insurance adjuster can't be dragged into a third-party demand by a nursing facility property owner over Hurricane Ida damage to its New Orleans location, finding that only "in very rare circumstances" would the adjuster have any duty to an insured.
-
September 20, 2024
5th Circ. Reverses Insurer's Early Win In Silo Damage Dispute
The Fifth Circuit reversed an insurer's early win in a coverage dispute with an agricultural cooperative over damage to two grain silos, instead finding that questions remained about whether wind and weather damage because of faulty construction qualified as property damage under the policy.
-
September 20, 2024
Insurers Say Ky. House Damage Wasn't From Mine Collapse
Insurers told a Kentucky federal court to toss a couple's case seeking compensation for damage to their home because of coal mine subsidence, arguing the damage wasn't caused by a collapsing void underground.
-
September 20, 2024
Mandarin Oriental Can Proceed With COVID Coverage Suit
A New York federal judge declined to toss a COVID-19 business interruption lawsuit by luxury international hotel chain Mandarin Oriental, holding that the chain sufficiently alleged that its loss was caused by an infectious disease under the terms outlined in its "all risks" policy.
-
September 19, 2024
Proposed $4B Hawaii Fire Deal Faces Insurance Questions
A proposed $4 billion settlement made on behalf of the victims of a 2023 wildfire in Hawaii could be imperiled depending on how the Hawaii Supreme Court approaches key questions concerning insurers' rights to recoup payments made to the victims.
-
September 19, 2024
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
The Ninth Circuit upheld tribal jurisdiction over the Suquamish Tribe's COVID-19 coverage claims, a New York federal court ruled that an insured's untimely notice doomed its coverage bid and a tax court rejected an oil leasing company's $1.1 million deduction for what the company called a "microcaptive insurance" program. Here, Law360 takes a look at the past week's top insurance news.
-
September 19, 2024
9th Circ. Won't Revive Hilton Builder's $7.5M Insurance Suit
Two insurers for a construction company have no duty to provide coverage for a more than $7.5 million water damage claim, the Ninth Circuit ruled Thursday, finding a rain damage exclusion in the company's policies is applicable.
-
September 18, 2024
Insurers Demand Arbitration Of La. Storm Damage At 2nd Circ.
A Second Circuit panel puzzled over whether to uphold a New York federal court's ruling denying surplus insurers arbitration in a Louisiana hurricane damage case, during oral arguments over whether the court should follow Bayou State law prohibiting arbitration or reverse the lower court's decision.
-
September 18, 2024
Climate's Toll On Property Insurance May Spur Broader Action
A flurry of state and local policymaking has sought to reconcile building needs with worsening weather events and rising construction and insurance costs, but this patchwork approach may soon be blanketed by federal action as financial stakeholders' analysis of climate risk evolves.
-
September 16, 2024
Fla. Condo Settles With Insurer Over Hurricane Ian Damage
A Florida condominium association seeking more than $1 million in coverage for property damage caused by a 2022 hurricane has settled with insurer Clear Blue Specialty Insurance Co.
-
September 13, 2024
The 2024 Regional Powerhouses
The law firms on Law360's list of 2024 Regional Powerhouses reflected the local peculiarities of their states while often representing clients in deals and cases that captured national attention.
-
September 12, 2024
Towers Watson Can't Duck Bump-Up Exclusion, 4th Circ. Told
Towers Watson's latest effort to get its directors and officers insurers to fund a $75 million settlement in a shareholder suit over its merger with Willis should be tossed, the insurers told the Fourth Circuit, saying the bump-up exclusion unambiguously applies to bar coverage.
-
September 11, 2024
Climate Risks Call For Proactive Resilience, Pros Say
Increasing climate change risks show the need for a more proactive approach to improving the resilience of high-risk communities, a task made more complicated by unabating development in high-risk areas and challenges in modeling and communicating risk.
-
September 10, 2024
London Reinsurance Sector Grew To £11B In 2023
The value of reinsurance transactions written in the London company insurance market grew by 33% in 2023 on the back of a harder pricing environment, according to figures published Tuesday by a trade body.
-
September 09, 2024
No Coverage For BNSF In Flood Suit, Travelers Says
Two Travelers units told a California federal court that they owe no additional insured coverage to railway giant BNSF over claims that a track relocation project it undertook caused significant flooding on a property owner's land.
-
September 09, 2024
Chinese Reinsurers Can't Exit Reimbursement Suit Yet
Two property insurers properly served Chinese reinsurers with their suit alleging that they owe more than $43 million in unpaid reinsurance claims, an Iowa federal court ruled, rejecting the reinsurers' argument that under the Hague Convention the insurers had to instead serve their suit via China's central authority.
-
September 06, 2024
Red Lobster Landlord Sues Zurich Over $1.2M Fire Payment
The owner of a property leased to Red Lobster said a Zurich unit negligently failed to name the owner on settlement checks issued to the eatery after a fire, telling a New Jersey federal court the failure allowed Red Lobster to avoid using the $1.2 million to make repairs.
-
September 05, 2024
Poor Communities Least Insured, Congressional Analyst Says
Flood risk in the United States is understated by official maps, and lower income communities have less insurance protection for greater risk — two problems that come as threats to U.S. housing grow, a congressional budget analyst said Thursday.
-
September 05, 2024
3rd Circ. Relieves Insurer Of Additional UIM Coverage
The Third Circuit reversed an early win a lower court handed to a couple whose son suffered serious injuries in a motorized dirt bike accident, finding that the couple's insurer needn't pay an additional $250,000 under another household policy because of the policy's household vehicle exclusion.
-
September 05, 2024
Notable D&O Rulings Of 2024 So Far
The U.S. Supreme Court’s corporate disclosure ruling, a California federal court’s take on advancement of subpoena-related defense costs and conflicting Delaware state court decisions on the enforcement of no-action clauses have set up 2024 as a big year for director and officer coverage rulings. Here, Law360 looks at five notable D&O rulings from the year so far.
-
September 05, 2024
Insurers Face Divided Regulator Response To AI Use Risks
Insurers are increasingly exploring methods for implementing artificial intelligence systems, and regulators across the United States are taking a variety of approaches to address concerns that such systems may exploit personal information or unfairly discriminate against consumers. Here, Law360 consults state insurance agencies to map out the insurer AI guidance landscape.
-
September 05, 2024
'Regrettable Mistake' Can't Bar Subrogation Bid, Insurer Says
An insurer for a Hardee's restaurant urged a North Carolina state appeals court to revive its subrogation action over a December 2019 fire, after it said its counsel made a "regrettable mistake" in naming a related brokerage as the plaintiff rather than the insurer itself.
-
September 05, 2024
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
The Fifth Circuit declined to revive a proposed global settlement related to the 2010 BP oil spill, a Hawaii federal judge determined a coverage dispute stemming from the 2023 Maui wildfires belonged in state court, and an Aon unit sought at least $140 million in damages from a Chinese bank.
-
September 05, 2024
Mound Cotton Brings On Litigation Duo In Fort Lauderdale
Mound Cotton Wollan & Greengrass LLP, which represents insurance companies, secured a pair of new partners for its Fort Lauderdale, Florida, office, one from Zelle LLP and another from Kelley Kronenberg.
Expert Analysis
-
How Ohio Software Ruling Implicates Crypto Insurance Claims
The Ohio Supreme Court's recent decision in EMOI Services v. Owners Insurance, holding that software can never be physically damaged, has limited precedential value for property claims, but serious implications for cases involving loss or damage to intangible assets like cryptocurrency and non-fungible tokens, say Jane Warring and Shannon O’Malley at Zelle.
-
Courts Should Reject Mandatory Arbitration In Insurance Suits
The case of Friends of Young Audiences v. Certain Underwriters, currently before a Louisiana federal court, is one of several pending opportunities for courts to support policyholder rights by declining to enforce mandatory arbitration provisions in insurance contracts, say Christopher Kuleba and Maria Castro Sanchez at Reed Smith.
-
What To Expect In Builder's Risk Insurance Claims In 2023
The builder's risk insurance industry is in store for more complex claims this year due to rising interest rates, labor and materials volatility, and externalities complicating project scheduling, say Jane Warring at Zelle and Michael Haugen at J.S. Held.
-
Learning From This Year's Legal Industry Discrimination Suits
To limit the risk of lawsuits and make the workplace a more welcoming environment for female attorneys, it is important to reflect on lawyers' recent discrimination and sexual harassment claims against law firms and public employers, says Hope Comisky at Griesing Law.
-
More Stringent Calif. Claim Law Could Benefit Policyholders
Although a new California statute that imposes additional requirements for policyholder presuit demands — effective Jan. 1 — was ostensibly passed as a bad faith liability shield for insurers, used correctly it may provide a more specific road map for plaintiff recovery, says Shanti Eagle at Farella Braun.
-
Hard Insurance Market Will Influence Legal Industry, Economy
As the cost of claims starts to outstrip the value of premiums, insurers are denying more claims and considering scaling back coverage, leading to an influx of legal work and potential holes in the market, says Bruce Hepburn at Mactavish.
-
Check This List Twice: 4 Steps To Abate Coverage Concerns
This holiday season give your company the gift of following easy administrative steps to avoid the far-too-common clerical errors that could lead to forfeited insurance coverage, say Vivek Chopra and Mattison Kim at Perkins Coie.
-
Lessons On Notice From 7th Circ. Claims-Made Policy Ruling
The Seventh Circuit's recent decision in Hanover Insurance v. R.W. Dunteman contains broad lessons for policyholders — as many claims-made policies include similar aggregation and claims notice provisions as the one at issue — on how to preserve coverage, say Brian Scarbrough and Maura Smyles at Jenner & Block.
-
Fla. Insurance Suit Trends To Look Out For After Hurricane Ian
There will likely be tens of thousands of property insurance lawsuits filed in the wake of Hurricane Ian, and carriers and insureds will need to view claims through Florida's Valued Policy Law, the concurrent cause doctrine and anti-concurrent cause provisions, say David Levin and Spencer Leach at Baker Donelson.
-
Property Policies Could Cover Organized Retail Crime Losses
Following a recent surge in organized retail crime, policyholders can look to case law that suggests they may be able to skirt property policy loss exclusions if they can produce evidence of theft, says Micah Skidmore at Haynes Boone.
-
Policyholders Are Not To Blame For Social Inflation
As part of the controversial assertion that insurers are facing an unprecedented increase in claims costs due to so-called social inflation, a recent Law360 guest article argued that policyholders contribute to social inflation and are therefore responsible for remedying it, but these accusations are unsupported by empirical data, says Benjamin Tievsky at Pillsbury.
-
How A Publication Request Helped Shape COVID Case Law
More than a decade after MRI Healthcare v. State Farm was decided in a California state appeals court, the case influenced the early development of COVID-19 business interruption insurance law and shows how counsel can use publication requests to help shape the industry, say Josephine Petrick and Ashley Nakai at Hanson Bridgett.
-
A Recovery Option For Lenders With Planes Stuck In Russia
For aircraft lessors considering insurance coverage litigation to recover for losses of equipment leased to Russian airlines, negotiating an assignment of rights may provide a faster pathway to recovery, say David Klein and Jose Lua-Valencia at Pillsbury.