Try our Advanced Search for more refined results
Intellectual Property - November, 2014
345 articles
- PTAB Bars Inventor From Proceeding Pro Se In AIA Review
- NY Firm Sues Ex-Partner For Stealing Client Files, Chairs
- Power Integrations Says Fairchild Lied In Patent Trial
- Revolving-Door Roundup: Gibson Dunn, Holland & Knight, Irell
- PTAB Says Same Prior Art May Lead To Different AIA Results
- Both Parties In 'Happy Birthday' Rights Row Vie For Quick Win
- IP MVP: Erise IP's Jason Mudd
- 9th Circ. Urged To Scrap 'Innocence Of Muslims' Injunction
- Amazon Returns Fire Over Porn Site's Injunction Bid
- Brand Battles: L'Oreal, Paramount, Monster Energy, Gap
- Fed. Circ. Clears Samsung, Others In Java Patent Case
- Williams-Sonoma, Ex-Employee Settle Trade Secrets Row
- Apple Wins Smartphone Patent Royalties From Samsung
- Qualcomm Asks Fed. Circ. To Nix Patents In ParkerVision Row
- What To Know About Extending Patent Term In Southeast Asia
- 3 Takeaways From Post-Octane Fitness Cases
- CVS, Rite Aid Settle Walgreens' Mobile Refill Patent Suit
- Samsung Can't Put Microsoft Royalty Row On Hold For Appeal
- Judge Tosses $105M Patent Verdict Against Fairchild
- Chrysler Slams Decades-Old 'Scat Pack' Mark Spat
- 3rd-Ever AIA Post-Grant Review Bid Lauched By Cattle Group
- IP MVP: WilmerHale's Bill Lee
- Ex-PilePro CFO Seeks To Disqualify Firm In IP Theft Case
- Tessera's $128M IP Arbitration Award Upheld By Calif. Court
- Hershey's Win Final In IP Suit Against UK Candy Importer
- 2nd-Ever Post-Grant Review Ends In Settlement
- Dish Can't Make Insurers Cover Patent Dispute, 10th Circ. Says
- Samsung Hit With TM Suit Over 'Milk' Streaming Music Service
- Judge Nixes Spine Surgery Patents, Citing Nautilus
- PTAB Offers Roadmap For Claim Amendments In AIA Reviews
- Judge Won't Toss Redskins Trademark Cancellation Suit
- Sears Wants Knockoff Windshield Blade Suit Wiped Away
- Remembering Doar: Justice As A 4-Letter Word
- Tech Cos. Back Google In High Court Street View IP Row
- 'Call Of Duty' Trademark Claims Tossed Over Free Speech
- Nossaman Fights DQ Bid In LED Trade Secrets Row
- US-India Forge Ahead On IP, Food Issues At Trade Summit
- Rubik's Cube Can Be Registered As Trademark, EU Court Says
- States Still Fighting Bad-Faith Patent Infringement Claims
- IP MVP: Morrison & Foerster's Rachel Krevans
- The 100 Law Firms With The Most IP Partners
- Samsung Escalates Nvidia Chip Patent Row With ITC Action
- ITC Has No Induced Infringement Power, Fed. Circ. Told
- Toshiba Calls ITC Patent Ruling 'Manifest Injustice'
- TV Networks Throw Weight Behind NCAA At 9th Circ.
- Retailers Defend Cert. Bid In Flash Memory Antitrust Suit
- Marvell Tells Fed. Circ. To Kill $1.5B Patent Verdict
- Don't Review Invalidation Of Apotex Patent, Fed. Circ. Told
- AstraZeneca Can't End Nexium Pay-For-Delay Trial
- Wal-Mart, Home Depot, Others Hit With Pool-Warmer TM Suit
- Corning Optical Gets 3 Cable Patents Nixed In AIA Reviews
- Steel Co. Denied Quick Win On Counterclaims Against Exec.
- Apple, Intel Back Microsoft In Landmark RAND Ruling Row
- Aereo Plans To Shop Infringing Streaming IP In Ch. 11
- Justices Asked To Weigh TM Suit Over Batman Movie Software
- 'Dark Horse' Writer Loses Bid For Atty Sanctions
- USTR Stumps For Better IP Protection Ahead Of India Summit
- Inventor Hits Mercedes With Latest Keyless Ignition Suit
- 10 Ways To Avoid Or Limit Institution In An AIA Proceeding
- Law360 Reveals 10 Largest IP Practice Groups
- Aereo's Gone, But Internet TV Is Here To Stay
- Phoenix Seeks To Cap $10M Software Claim At $500K
- Private Copyright Cop Sued For Bogus DMCA Subpoenas
- After Facebook Fails, Google Shoots For Photo Patent Review
- Altair Clinches New Damages Trial In MSC Secrets Fight
- NuScience Atty Tests Judge's Patience At IP Sanctions Hearing
- Nexium Pay-For-Delay Plaintiffs Can't Prove Conspiracy
- Westinghouse Data Patent Again Targeted For AIA Review
- Pandora Isn't Guaranteed Access To BMI's Songs, Judge Says
- Perkins Coie Snags Tech-Loving IP Pro For NY Office
- Antitrust Professors Back NCAA Appeal Of Athlete Pay Ruling
- Sens. Lean On Customs To Shore Up IP Enforcement
- Schlumberger Questions SLAPP Ruling In Trade Secret Appeal
- IP MVP: Paul Weiss' Nicholas Groombridge
- Differentiate Your Litigation Practice With Data Security
- IP Professors Q&A: Washington University's Kevin Collins
- Aereo Files For Ch. 11 In Bid To Dodge Copyright Suits
- Is Stockpiling Protected By Hatch-Waxman Safe Harbor?
- Fed Circ. Threatens Sanctions For Redacted Legal Args
- Edible Arrangements Delivers $97M IP Suit To 1-800-Flowers
- Ariz. Deepens States' Rift On UTSA Preemption
- Sirius Denied Quick Trip To 9th Circ. Over Pre-'72 Recordings
- Texas Court Denies Tax Assessor's Valero Rehearing Request
- USPTO Official Says New Eligibility Rules Will Quell Fears
- EU Court Adviser Sets Plan For Essential Patent Injunctions
- Fed. Circ. Orders Sales Patent Case Stayed For AIA Review
- Google, Cisco, Time Warner Cable Settle Rockstar IP War
- Judge Scolds Kirkland & Ellis Attys In Ranbaxy-FDA Row
- AstraZeneca Seeks Judgment In Nexium Pay-For-Delay Case
- IP MVP: McDermott Will & Emery's William Gaede
- Patent Holder Matches Sony's Sanctions Bid In IP Fight
- High Times Slaps 'High Times Lifestyle' With Trademark Suit
- Sanctions Sought For IP Firm's 'Baseless' $42M Counterclaim
- 2 Assumptions Shape 3rd Circ. Reverse Payment Case
- Brand Owner-Friendly UDRP Decision Reinterprets Bad Faith
- The Print Room: How To Spend Less And Get More
- Walgreen Settles With Rival Over Poached Employees
- 'Rock Band' Co. Harmonix Seeks AIA Review Of Audio Patent
- NCAA Loses Fight To Depose Ex-Hausfeld Atty On $51M Fees
- Ex-Aruba Networks Exec Launches New IP Firm
- IP MVP: Durie Tangri's Daralyn Durie
- Ariz. Justices Say UTSA Only Preempts Trade Secrets Claims
- Par Pharma Says Its New Drug Won't Rip Off GSK's Lamictal
- Ariosa Gets Stanford DNA Test Patent Nixed In AIA Review
- 3rd Circ. Told Actavis Allows Noncash Settlement Scrutiny
- Fed. Circ. Revives Flash Memory Patent Suit Against Huawei
- Fed. Circ. Bars Claim Relitigation In E.Digital Patent Row
- Ranbaxy Seeks Mistrial In Nexium Pay-For-Delay Case
- White House Says Illegal Online Streaming Should Be Felony
- PTAB To Eye Sipco Network Patent Asserted Against Comcast
- Apple-Samsung Judge Rips 'Ridiculous' Nokia Bid To Seal
- 'Porn Troll' Attys Escape Sanctions In Copyright Suit
- Sirius Drops Weil, Adds O'Melveny For Pre-'72 Cases
- Royalty Pharma Pays $3.3B For Cystic Fibrosis Drug Royalties
- Tips For Dealing With Competing IPR And ITC Deadlines
- IBM Scores $5.2M In Intermec Patent Licensing Row
- Law360 MVP Awards Go To Legal Aces From 78 Firms
- Novo Nordisk Pays $19M To Settle Prandin Antitrust Action
- PTAB Rejects L-3 AIA Reviews For Failure To Show Prior Art
- Finnegan Blasts 'Surprise' $2M Sanction In Dow IP Suit
- Reps. Want Crackdown On USPTO Telework Abuse
- LifeNet Wins $35M Verdict In Tissue Graft Patent Suit
- Gymboree Says Kmart, Bon-Ton Selling Knockoff Apparel
- Ultratec Wants Fees After $44M Phone Patent Trial
- Fed. Circ. Revives Navigation IP Suit Against AT&T, Verizon
- Sirius Says Pre-'72 Performance Right Violates Comm. Clause
- CORRECTED: Pharmas Can't Nix Lidoderm MDL Over $170M Pay-For-Delay Deals
- Sony Wants Former In-House Counsel DQ'd In Patent Row
- Fed. Circ. Affirms Warner Chilcott's Actonel Patents Invalid
- Congress To Push Patent Troll Bill In 2015, Goodlatte Says
- BakerHostetler Snags Tech Patent Pro For DC Office
- Microsoft Urges 9th Circ. To Affirm Landmark RAND Ruling
- Patent Troll Bill Just Part Of The Fix, App Group Head Says
- Dewey Partner Clawback Ruling May Hurt New York Law Firms
- Twombly, Iqbal And The Demise Of Form 18
- Citing Soul Hit, 11th Circ. Affirms $1.3M Axiom TM Win
- Hershey Nears Win In IP Suit Against Importer Of UK Candy
- Apple, Amazon Quickly Core Suit Over iPad Cover Sales
- Original-Patent Rule Dooms Drug Injection Complaint
- Licensee Can't Revive AT&T, Verizon Infringement Suits
- Fredrikson Drops Sanctions Bid To End IP Malpractice Row
- Apple Pushes PTAB To Nix PersonalWeb's Data Patent Claims
- Vegas Strip Club Rivals Take Trademark Fight To 9th Circ.
- Ex-Pond Lehocky Atty Says Sense Of Betrayal Prompted Suit
- Judge Recuses Herself In Cochran Firm Trademark Suit
- NCAA Says High Court Precedent Supports Athlete Pay Ban
- 3rd Circ. To Decide If Reverse Payments Must Be Cash
- Law Prof Loses Fight Over Brief In $173M Qualcomm Appeal
- Fed. Circ. Revives Malico's CPU-Cooler Patent Suit
- Ex-Siemens Patent Atty Accuses Company Of Age Bias
- Carl's Jr. Hit With Trademark Suit For 'Mile High' Burgers
- Ranbaxy Sues FDA Over Nixed Approvals Of Generics
- Travelers Needn't Defend Law Firm In Rival's Privacy Suit
- Lead Attorney Sanctioned In Scotts Seed IP Dispute
- Arent Fox, Manatt Sued For Involvement In Betty Boop IP Spat
- Minority Powerbrokers Q&A: Irell & Manella's Morgan Chu
- Post-Grant Review May Impact Biosimilars Litigation
- Crumbs Decision Protects TM Licensees' 365(n) IP Rights
- Samsung Loses Arbitration Bid In Microsoft IP Licensing Row
- Kilpatrick Urges Toss Of Medication-Cart IP Theft Claims
- Layoffs, Liquidation May Follow Bingham, Morgan Lewis Deal
- Sirius Can't Shake Turtles' $100M Royalties Suit In NY
- Fed. Circ. Ad Patent Ruling Will Spur Early Alice Attacks
- Fed. Circ. Kills Ultramercial Online-Ad Patent As Abstract
- Brand Battles: EBay, Philip Morris, 'WTF'
- Starbucks Seeks AIA Review Of Incentive Program Patent
- Philips Wants To Drain $467M Blood Sensor IP Verdict
- Lost Coast Loses Shark TM Suit Over Rival Beer Label
- Judge's Conversion Of IP Firm To Gen. Partnership Reversed
- Fed. Circ. Upholds Most Of PTAB Chip Patent Decision
- Panasonic Urges High Court To Kill Memory Card Cartel Suit
- 'Dark Horse' Writer Rips Attys For Citing Kesha Assault Row
- Starbucks Having Trouble Winning Coffee Cup Trademark
- IP Professors Q&A: Dedman's David Taylor
- LinkedIn Can't Claim Immunity In Email Harvesting Brawl
- Morgan Lewis Partners Approve Bingham Deal
- PTAB Grants Infomotion Review Of Smart Basketball Patent
- Can Employers Be Vicariously Liable Under CFAA?
- ITC Trends Medical Device Companies Should Know About
- Oracle Takes Reduced $357M Award In SAP Copyright Suit
- Fed. Circ. Trims Sanctions Order In Prison Toothbrush Suit
- Finnegan Atty Named To Fed. Circ. Hailed For Patent Prowess
- Overstock, Sears Selling Copycat 'Love Grows' Jewelry: Suit
- Judge Can't Hear Infringement In Jay-Z's 'Run This Town'
- Mattel Can't Shake MGA's $1B Bratz Trade Secrets Suit
- ITC To Investigate Alleged Knockoff Chuck Taylor Imports
- What's In A Name? When 'Just Mayo' Isn't 'Mayonnaise'
- Choice Hotels, BNY Mellon Accused Of Flouting Data Input IP
- Tory Burch 'Counterfeiters' Faked Docs In TM Suit
- Goodwin Procter Nabs Ex-K&L Gates IP Pro
- Uber Can Operate In Pa. But Not Philly, Regulator Says
- Minority Powerbrokers Q&A: Greenberg Traurig's Becerra
- Dr. Reddy's Denied Quick Win In Consultant Noncompete Row
- Finnegan Atty Tapped To Replace Rader On Fed. Circ.
- Parrish V. Latham Hasn't Changed Malicious Prosecution
- Courts May Be Applying Gunn V. Minton Improperly
- Ex-McKool Atty Wants To Hit Firm With Human Trafficking Suit
- Patent Troll Insurance Useful If Buyers Read Fine Print
- Jury Finds 'Cosby Show' Co-Creator Didn't Steal Show Idea
- LinkedIn Gets Web Sale Patent Claims Nixed As Abstract
- Damon Dash Can't Be Defamed, Lee Daniels' Co-Producer Says
- Married Lawyers Suspected Of Stabbing Law Firm Boss
- Allergan Wants Miotox Patent Invalidated In $600M Botox Row
- Rosa Parks Institute Says Target Merch Is Not Free Speech
- Giants Fake Memorabilia Suit Booted From Federal Court
- Google Wins 9th Circ. En Banc Rehearing In 'Muslims' Row
- Braintree Asks High Court To Hear Claim Construction Row
- Sidley Austin Nabs Reed Smith IP Litigation Partner
- Vegas Sands Says $5B Macau Licensing Suit Is A Repeat
- Don't Read Too Much Into AbbVie Case, FTC's Feinstein Says
- Commil Urges Justices To Eye Instructions To Cisco IP Jury
- Audi, VW Accused Of Infringing Display System Patents
- Minority Powerbrokers Q&A: Morgan Lewis' Daniel Johnson
- Takeaways From TTAB's 1st Fraud Ruling In Years
- Becton Must Pony Up $340M In Syringe Antitrust Suit
- DuPont Stole Irrigation System Trade Secrets, Suit Says
- 'Cosby Show' Co-Creator's Show-Stealing Row In Jury's Hands
- Nokia Spurns Apple, Tells Fed. Circ. To Revive $368M Award
- Kedem Accuses Ex-Biz Partner Of Deleting Emails In IP Suit
- Keith Haring Foundation Seeks Sanctions In Defamation Row
- Wellogix Claims Against SAP Tossed Over Jurisdiction
- Samsung Hits Nvidia, Velocity With Patent, False-Ad Suit
- Activision Ruling May Signal Shift In Transformative Use
- Kuwait Draws Closer US Scrutiny As IP Problems Persist
- High Court Won't Hear Appeal On E-Pay IP Declaratory Suit
- Drug Cos. Seek Judgment In Nexium Pay-For-Delay Case
- Obama Inks Visa Pact With China, But Flags IP, Ag Woes
- Publishers Want En Banc Rehearing On GSU Fair Use Ruling
- Oracle Can't Ditch Antitrust Claims In Sun Copyright Suit
- Pandora Says Publishers Used BMI Withdrawal To 'Extort'
- PTAB Nixes Bose Speaker Patents In AIA Reviews
- Game Show Network Gets Gaming Patent Nixed In AIA Review
- Converse Blitz Highlights ITC As Overlooked Trademark Venue
- Minority Powerbrokers Q&A: Akin Gump's Anthony Pierce
- Linklaters Adds Ex-DLA Piper German Patent Litigation Head
- Del. Court Is 1st To Apply Daimler To Hatch-Waxman Case
- Intel, Acer Get Plug Pulled On Ethernet Patent Brawl
- Nortel Gets Discovery Relief in Rockstar IP Fight
- Brand Battles: CVS, Starbucks, The Hobbit
- High Court To Settle Rift On Service Deadline Extensions
- FTC Settlement With 'Patent Troll' May Signal Wider Action
- Fed. Circ. Boots Network Patent Owner From Broadcom Suit
- Attys Tend To 'Buy Themselves Off' In Class Deals, Judge Says
- Mentor Graphics Slams Synopsys' IP As 'Mental Processes'
- Marvel Subpoenas Google To Find 'Avengers' Trailer Leaker
- Fenwick Client VoxerNet Wins $820K Fee Award In Patent Case
- Apple Pulled 'Bait And Switch,' Says COO Of Bankrupt GTAT
- ITC To Probe Claimed Patent-Infringing Segway Knockoffs
- Apple Tells Fed. Circ. Not To Reinstate $368M VirnetX Verdict
- Ex-GC Can't Kill Slot Machine Maker's Trade Secrets Suit
- AT&T, Verizon, Others Flouted U. Of Minn. Patents, Suit Says
- 5 Insights From Honeywell General Counsel Kate Adams
- IP Professors Q&A: Santa Clara's Brian Love
- The Right Way To Use Evidentiary Declarations Under AIA
- 'Patent Troll' To End Deceptive Tactics In Deal With FTC
- Reprimand In Rader Email Flap Shows Pitfalls Of Boasting
- FDA Yanks Ranbaxy's Approvals For Generic Nexium, Valcyte
- Fed. Circ. Upholds Microsoft, Google Win On Auction Patent
- Antonelli Terry Rips Bid To Double $8M Malpractice Verdict
- Weird Marks: 3 Tips For Using Nontraditional Trademarks
- Ga. Port Snags 3rd Major Counterfeit Shipment Of 2014
- Champagne Taittinger Subsidiary Sued Over Wine Brand Mark
- ManattJones Nabs KPMG Partner To Run New Office In Mexico
- HomeGoods Accused Of Ripping Off Palm-Tree Glass Design
- ClearPlay's DVD Censoring Patent Survives AIA Review
- Dorsey Snags PTAB Pioneer For Denver IP Team
- Applera Urges Fed. Circ. To Nix Enzo DNA Patent Win
- Greenberg Adds Bingham IP, Privacy Pro To Calif. Office
- 5 Ways To Uncover Bias During Jury Selection
- Secondary Considerations For Pharma Patents Get 2nd Look
- Broker Pleads Guilty After SEC BigLaw Tipster Case
- Lyft Accuses Ex-COO Of Taking Secret Docs To Rival Uber
- FTC Investigating Qualcomm Licensing For FRAND Violations
- Endo, Teikoku Monopoly Claims Likely Out In Lidoderm MDL
- 9th Circ. OKs Netgear Engineer Conviction For Secrets Theft
- 'Rambling' Inventor Can't Shake Cowan Liebowitz Sanctions
- Barbri Says Broken Noncompete Puts Secrets At Risk
- Atty Takes $90K Hit For Baseless IP Suit Against Indybay
- Pfizer Nixes Pharmacists' Claims In Lipitor Pay-To-Delay Row
- Polaris Gets Device Locator Patent Nixed In AIA Review
- Fed. Circ. Revives Web Conference IP Suit Against Microsoft
- How Senate Without Filibuster-Proof Majority Avoids Gridlock
- Walgreen Blood Tester Throws Down Gauntlet In Rival TM Row
- Nexium Buyers Seek Litigation Docs From AstraZeneca
- Ford, GM's Bid For Fees In Display IP Row Called Premature
- Google, LG Strike Patent Cross-Licensing Deal
- Kerry Backs Chinese Investment Pact But Wants Action On IP
- Fresenius Brings Antibiotics Row With Cubist To PTAB
- Weil Atty Reprimanded By Fed. Circ. For Sharing Rader Email
- GM Denied Sanctions In Hybrid Car Battery Patent Suit
- 7th Circ. Unveils Limits Of Confidentiality Agreements
- The Odds Of Getting A Case Stayed Pending AIA Review
- What You Should Know About Changes To Canada Patent Law
- IP Bills Have Momentum In New Congress
- TiVo Sanctioned For Bad Grammar In Patent Fight
- Eon Wins $13M From Silver Spring In Telecom Patent Suit
- Apple, GT Proceed With Settlement After Records Unsealed
- Symantec Gets Claims Nixed In Columbia's Malware IP Row
- BMI Tells Pandora Publishers Won't Pull Song Rights Soon
- Adaptix Says No Evidence Its Patents Used AT&T Secrets
- 'Cosby Show' Co-Creator Says He Didn't Steal TV Show Idea
- 'Raging Bull' Boosts Patent Laches Defense, Fed. Circ. Told
- CBS Must Turn Over Ad Revenue Info In Dish Ad-Skip Row
- Jury Orders B&N To Pay $1.3M In Nook Patent Row
- Fed. Circ. Questions AIA Review Rules In 1st-Ever Appeal
- Thai Police Nab Pirate Bay Co-Founder After Years On The Lam
- Jay-Z, Kanye Ripped Off 'Made In America,' Suit Says
- Tivoli Demands DQ Of Its Former Atty In Trade Secrets Row
- Wal-Mart Ends 'RedNek Wine Glass' Infringement Suit
- WWE Can Smack Down 'Fly By Night' Counterfeiters: 5th Circ.
- Enfish's IP Claims Against Microsoft Declared Unpatentable
- GoDaddy Can't Escape Automated-Email Patent Suit
- HTC Defends $4.8M Fee Request In Messaging Patent Suit
- Turtles Say Sirius Can't Go To 9th Circ. Over Pre-1972s
- Retailers Can't Stay Discovery In SanDisk IP Antitrust Suit
- Ohio Man Pleads Guilty To $1.7M Android App Piracy
- ITC Adds $2M To Finnegan's Spoliation Sanction In Dow Suit
- Cadwalader Snags Ex-MoFo Patent Pro For DC, Hong Kong
- Telemundo Wins Access To Privileged Docs In IP Fight
- Norton Rose Fulbright Snags 2 Cybersecurity, Privacy Pros
- Google Fights En Banc Bid Of Nixed $30M Vringo Verdict
- Cochran Firm Blasts Gamesmanship By Ex-Partner's Counsel
- True Value Sues Pesticide Co. Over 'Green Thumb' Marks
- Osha Liang Client Sanctioned Over Discovery Violations
- Usher, Sony Win Atty Fees In Copyright Row Over 'Bad Girl'
- How The Redskins Decision Impacts Brand Value And The NFL
- Double Patenting: Old Tool For Generics And Biosimilars
- Minority Powerbrokers Q&A: White & Case's Bijal Vakil
- Apple Plugs In WilmerHale Trio To Lobby On IP, Competition
- Ultratec Gets Closed-Caption Patent Nixed In AIA Review
- Generic Drug Patent Cases On The Rise In 2014, Report Says
- Google Loses Bid For AIA Review Of PersonalWeb Patents
- High Court Won't Hear Sherlock Holmes Copyright Case
- Supreme Court Won't Hear Recusal Row In DuPont Kevlar Case
- Calls Grow For Fed. Circ. To Eye Laches Post-'Raging Bull'
- High Court Lets Stand Ex-Dorsey & Whitney Atty's 7-Year Ban
- TTAB Preclusion Raises Constitutional Issues, High Court Told
- Trademark Tacking Is Jury Question, US Tells High Court
- Samsung Says Microsoft's Nokia Buy Flouted Licensing Deal
- Sidense Fights For $9M Atty Fees After Win In Patent Suit
- Visa Loses Bid To Nix Transaction Patent In AIA Review
- Buying Patents To Thwart 'Trolls' Is A Tricky Strategy
- 3rd Circ. OKs FTC To Join Lamictal Oral Arguments
- Plot Thickens For Screenplay Infringement Cases
- Bristol-Myers V. Teva: What Doomed The Entecavir Patent